As Emmy nomination voting officially closed on June 23, TV critics and industry insiders sent in their final picks. While big-name shows are expected to dominate the headlines once again, there’s always room for a surprise or two. This year, one unexpected contender is getting fans excited — the reboot of Matlock.
Yes, the classic courtroom drama is back with a new twist, and it’s led by none other than award-winning actress Kathy Bates. With a smart update to its original formula and a standout performance from Bates, the new Matlock could finally earn the recognition it deserves.
Kathy Bates gives Matlock a fresh edge
In the 2025 reboot, Kathy Bates plays Madeline Matlock, a modern reimagining of the beloved character once portrayed by Andy Griffith. Bates brings her signature sharpness, wit, and emotional depth to the role. Her version of Matlock is confident, clever, and deeply human — a perfect balance that makes each courtroom scene engaging.
While Bates is already known for her past Emmy wins and powerful roles, her work in Matlock is something new. She gives the character a strong voice in today’s world, where experience and wisdom are often overlooked. Bates reminds viewers that age brings insight, and justice still matters.
Why Matlock is being overlooked
Despite the quality of the show, Matlock faces a common challenge. Procedural dramas on traditional networks like CBS often don’t get much love from the Emmys. Streaming platforms and big-budget dramas usually take center stage. But this pattern is starting to shift.
Recent shows like Poker Face and The Residence have shown that procedurals can be both entertaining and award-worthy. So why not Matlock? The new series has strong writing, timely themes, and a performance from Bates that is hard to ignore.
Telling relevant stories with a classic formula
What makes Matlock special is its ability to stay true to its roots while still addressing today’s biggest issues. The show tackles topics like corporate corruption and bias in the legal system with a thoughtful approach. Its courtroom structure helps keep the storytelling tight and focused, without losing emotional impact.
Procedural shows are often labeled as predictable, but Matlock proves they can still deliver powerful, character-driven stories. The formula works — especially when it’s done this well.
A strong team behind the scenes
Matlock also features a talented supporting cast and a variety of guest stars who help keep the episodes fresh. Similar to CBS’s Elsbeth, which is also gaining Emmy buzz, Matlock builds a world where each character adds something meaningful. And just like Carrie Preston shines in Elsbeth, Kathy Bates owns every scene she’s in.
Both shows challenge the idea that network TV can’t compete with streaming content. They prove that good storytelling and great acting matter more than the platform.
Why this moment matters for Matlock
With Emmy nominations set to be announced on July 15, there’s hope that Matlock will break through the usual lineup. It may not be the flashiest contender, but it has everything an Emmy-worthy show needs — great writing, an unforgettable lead, and a message that speaks to today’s world.
Award shows often miss the chance to honor network TV shows that do things right. This year, the Emmys have a chance to change that. Matlock deserves its place in the spotlight, and Kathy Bates deserves to be recognized for a role that’s both powerful and important.
Let’s hope the voters take notice — because this time, justice deserves to be served.